Skip to content

AlternativesMaker & seller marketplaces

Etsy Alternatives for Handmade and Vintage Sellers

Etsy alternatives for makers and vintage sellers: Amazon Handmade, eBay, Big Cartel, Faire, Tedooo and print on demand, compared on fees from each site's own pages.

Disclosure: we may earn a commission if you sign up or buy through links on this page. It costs you nothing extra and never decides a quick answer, a switch card or an Our pick tag. How we make money.

Artistic setup of pottery tools and unpainted ceramic mugs ready for glazing on a table.
Photo: Esra Koçyiğit / Pexels

Quick answer

Most makers look for Etsy alternatives because fees stack on every sale: $0.20 per listing, 6.5% of item plus shipping, 3% + $0.25 for payments, and up to 15% more when an Offsite Ad makes the sale12. Switch to Amazon Handmade if you can pass its application and want the monthly plan fee waived3, Big Cartel if you’d rather run your own shop with 0% transaction fees6, and Faire if you’re ready to sell wholesale to shops8.

Amazon HandmadeBest for approved makers who want a big marketplace without a monthly plan fee
eBayBest for vintage and one-of-a-kind sellers who list a lot of items
Big CartelBest for makers who want their own shop with a flat monthly price
FaireBest for makers ready to sell wholesale to retail shops
TedoooBest for hobby makers who want a free, social place to list
GelatoBest for designers who want print-on-demand products on several channels

At a glance

The alternatives at a glance

#PlatformBest forFees or starting priceLink
01 Amazon Handmade Approved makers who want a big marketplace without a monthly plan fee 15% referral fee per unit (min $0.30); Pro plan fee waived after month onechecked 2026-11-21 Visit (opens in a new tab)
02 eBay Vintage and one-of-a-kind sellers who list a lot of items 250 free listings/mo, then $0.35; 13.6% + $0.30-$0.40 per orderchecked 2026-11-21 Visit (opens in a new tab)
03 Big Cartel Makers who want their own shop with a flat monthly price Free for 5 products; Platinum $15/mo; Diamond $30/mochecked 2026-11-21 Visit (opens in a new tab)
04 Faire Makers ready to sell wholesale to retail shops 15% commission on marketplace orders (+$10 on a new retailer's first order); 0% on Faire Directchecked 2026-11-21 Visit (opens in a new tab)
05 Tedooo Hobby makers who want a free, social place to list No selling fees; optional Pro membershipchecked 2026-11-21 Visit (opens in a new tab)
06 Gelato Designers who want print-on-demand products on several channels Free to start; pay product + shipping per order, no commissionchecked 2026-11-21 Visit (opens in a new tab)

Fees and prices as each platform's own page listed them on the date shown, in US dollars, before tax and payment processing unless the row says otherwise. Confirm on the platform before you move.

Etsy fees used to be one line. Now they stack. If you’re weighing Etsy alternatives, the reason is usually written in Etsy’s own fee policy: $0.20 to list each item for four months, 6.5% of the item price plus shipping when it sells, 3% + $0.25 to process the payment in the US, and a 12% or 15% Offsite Ads fee when an Etsy ad on another site brought the buyer12. This guide compares where handmade and vintage sellers move instead, on each platform’s own fee pages, checked today. We rank by fit, not by commission; see how we compare and our editorial policy.

Why sellers leave Etsy

The fees are the first reason, and they are easy to underestimate because each one is charged on a different base:

  • Listing fee. $0.20 per item, charged whether or not it sells. Listings expire after four months, and auto-renew charges another $0.20 each time1.
  • Transaction fee. 6.5% of the price you display plus what you charge for shipping and gift wrap1.
  • Payment processing. For US bank accounts, 3% + $0.25, on the total sale including tax and shipping12.
  • Offsite Ads. 15% of the order total on attributed orders while you’re under $10,000 in yearly sales, and you can opt out. Cross $10,000 and it drops to 12% but becomes mandatory for the life of the shop. The cap is $100 per order1.
  • Set-up fee. Etsy may charge a one-time fee to open a shop, shown during set-up1.

Take a $40 necklace with $8 shipping. Etsy keeps $5.01 of the $48: $0.20 to list, $3.12 transaction fee, $1.69 processing (before sales tax). If the buyer came through an Offsite Ad, another $7.20 goes, and you keep $35.7912.

Here is how the same order looks on the marketplaces in this guide that charge per sale, using each one’s own fee page:

Platform What it charges the seller On a $40 item + $8 shipping You keep
Etsy $0.20 listing + 6.5% + 3% + $0.25 $5.01 $42.99
Etsy, Offsite Ads sale the above + 15% of the order $12.21 $35.79
eBay (most categories) 13.6% + $0.40 per order $6.93 $41.07
Amazon Handmade 15% referral fee (min $0.30) $7.20 $40.80

Sources:1234. All figures are before sales tax, which Etsy and eBay also charge their percentage on, and before you pay for postage.

Payouts are fine on Etsy: you choose daily, weekly, biweekly or monthly deposits, which generally land within five business days2, and eligible US sellers can use instant transfer1. So the case for switching is mostly about fees and control, not about getting paid.

ChartWhat you keep from one $48 order
  • Etsy$5.01 in fees $42.99
  • Etsy (Offsite Ads sale)plus a 15% Offsite Ads fee $35.79
  • eBay$6.93 in fees $41.07
  • Amazon Handmade$7.20 referral fee $40.80

Bars scaled from 0 · US dollars kept

A $40 item with $8 buyer-paid shipping ($48 total), before sales tax and before you pay for postage. Etsy: $0.20 listing + 6.5% + 3% + $0.25. Amazon Handmade: 15%. eBay: 13.6% + $0.40 (most categories). Big Cartel, Tedooo and Faire are left out because their pages don’t price the same retail sale on one basis.

Sources: [1] [2] [3] [4] · checked 2026-11-21Download image

1. Amazon Handmade

Amazon Handmade product image
Amazon Handmade (image: sell.amazon.com)
Leaving

Etsy

  • Reason: 6.5% transaction fee on item price plus shipping1
Switch to

Amazon Handmade

  • You gain: $39.99/mo Pro plan waived after month one3
  • You gain: Transfer product details over from Etsy3
  • You give up: 15% referral fee per unit, minimum $0.303
  • You give up: You have to apply and be approved3

Switch to Amazon Handmade if you make everything yourself, can pass an application, and want one simple per-sale fee. Amazon deducts a 15% referral fee or $0.30, whichever is greater, for every unit shipped3. Handmade requires a Professional selling plan, which typically costs $39.99 a month, but after a one-time first-month payment the fee is waived for approved Handmade sellers3. Amazon says you create a storefront for free and pay referral fees only when you sell3.

What counts: products that are hand-altered, hand-designed, handcrafted, repurposed or upcycled, and Amazon runs an application and audit process to keep it that way3. Approved makers and collaborative groups such as cooperatives and nonprofits can sell3. If you already sell on Etsy, Amazon lets you transfer product details over3. Check your category first: Handmade covers accessories, artwork, baby, beauty, clothing and shoes, home, jewelry, kitchen, pet supplies, sporting goods, stationery and party supplies, and toys, and items from unlisted categories may not be sold in the Handmade store3.

One catch for personalized work: custom products have to be fulfilled by you and can’t use Fulfillment by Amazon3. On our $48 order, the 15% fee is $7.20, more than Etsy’s $5.01 on a regular sale but the same as Etsy’s Offsite Ads fee alone13.

2. eBay

Leaving

Etsy

  • Reason: $0.20 per listing, renewed every four months1
Switch to

eBay

  • You gain: 250 listings a month with no insertion fee4
  • You gain: Payouts start daily by default5
  • You give up: 13.6% + $0.40 per order in most categories4

Switch to eBay if you sell vintage or list a lot of one-off pieces and Etsy’s $0.20 per listing adds up. eBay gives sellers without a Store 250 listings a month with no insertion fee, then charges $0.35 per listing4. When something sells, the final value fee in most categories is 13.6% of the total sale up to $7,500, plus $0.30 on orders of $10 or less or $0.40 above4. That total includes shipping, handling and sales tax4.

On our $48 order, eBay takes $6.93 before tax4. Payouts are initiated daily by default, funds typically show as available within 48 hours of the buyer’s payment, and your bank usually takes 1-3 business days; express payouts arrive in about 30 minutes for a flat $25.

Watch the rules that raise the bill: a 1.65% international fee when a US seller ships abroad without eBay International Shipping, and an extra 6% on final value fees for a month after you’re rated Below Standard4.

3. Big Cartel

Big Cartel product image
Big Cartel (image: bigcartel.com)
Leaving

Etsy

  • Reason: Offsite Ads fee of 12-15% on attributed orders1
Switch to

Big Cartel

  • You gain: 0% transaction fees on every plan6
  • You gain: Import your products from Etsy6
  • You give up: Free Gold plan caps you at 5 products7
  • You give up: Platinum is $15/mo after a 7-day trial6

Switch to Big Cartel if you’d rather pay a flat monthly price than a cut of each sale. Big Cartel charges 0% transaction fees on all plans6. The free Gold plan covers 5 product listings with cards and PayPal and sales tax autopilot7. Platinum is 7 days free, then $15 a month, with custom domains, shipping labels and a print-on-demand studio; Diamond is $30 a month and adds abandoned cart recovery and scheduled product drops6. It also imports products from Etsy6.

The trade: Big Cartel is a shop builder, not a marketplace. Its plans sell tools for promoting your products on Google, Meta and social, so the buyers come from wherever you send them6. The 0% is Big Cartel’s own cut; the pricing page doesn’t list card or PayPal processing rates, so check those with your payment provider.

4. Faire

Faire product image
Faire (image: faire.com)
Leaving

Etsy

  • Reason: Fees stack per sale: 6.5% + 3% + $0.2512
Switch to

Faire

  • You gain: 0% commission on retailers you bring yourself9
  • You gain: Payout as soon as the day after shipping8
  • You give up: 15% + $10 on a new marketplace retailer8

Switch to Faire if you’re ready to sell wholesale to retail shops instead of one piece at a time to shoppers. In North America, Faire’s standard marketplace commission is 15%, plus a one-time $10 fee on a new retailer’s first order; reorders are 15%8. Retailers you bring yourself through Faire Direct pay you at 0% commission on all their orders89.

Payment processing depends on how fast you want the money: 3.5% + $0.30 for a payout the day after an order ships, 2.4% + $0.30 at 30 days, or 1.9% + $0.30 at 60 days, with funds typically in your bank 1-3 business days after Faire sends them8. Your payout is the wholesale subtotal plus any shipping reimbursement, minus commission and processing8, so price your wholesale line with that in mind.

5. Tedooo

Tedooo product image
Tedooo (image: tedooo.com)
Leaving

Etsy

  • Reason: Every listing costs $0.20, sold or not1
Switch to

Tedooo

  • You gain: Zero selling fees, unlimited listings10
  • You give up: Search priority is a paid Pro perk11

Switch to Tedooo if you sell a handful of pieces as a hobby and mostly want a free place to show them. Tedooo says you can open a shop, list unlimited products and keep 100% of your earnings, with no commissions10. It welcomes handmade items, personalized gifts, custom work, vintage finds and secondhand pieces, and pairs the shop with a social feed and a maker community it puts at over 1 million people10.

The paid layer is Pro: search priority, a boosted profile, a verified badge, custom offer pages and 50 photo-enhancement credits a month11. Tedooo’s own pages are the only source here, so treat the community size as their claim.

6. Gelato

Leaving

Etsy

  • Reason: Etsy’s 6.5% fee also applies to shipping1
Switch to

Gelato

  • You gain: No commission or minimum order12
  • You gain: Sell on Amazon, TikTok Shop or your own site12
  • You give up: You pay product + shipping on each order12

Switch some of your range to Gelato if your products are your designs, such as prints, cards, mugs or tees, and you want them on more than one channel. Gelato charges no commission and no upfront fee: when a customer orders, you pay Gelato the product and shipping cost and it prints and ships from the production partner nearest the customer12. There’s no minimum order, and the optional Gelato+ subscription adds product discounts12. It connects to Etsy, Amazon, TikTok Shop, WooCommerce, Squarespace and other stores12.

Two other print-on-demand services are worth a look. Printify is free to start, with a Premium plan at $39 a month (or $24.99 a month billed yearly) that takes up to 20% off most products, and it connects to Etsy, eBay, Amazon and TikTok Shop13. Tapstitch focuses on premium apparel with no upfront costs and a minimum order of one item, and US fulfillment of its bestselling items from Los Angeles14.

How to choose between Etsy alternatives

Start with how you sell, not with the lowest percentage:

  • One-of-a-kind and vintage, lots of listings: eBay’s 250 free listings a month beat paying $0.20 for each one14.
  • Handmade, sold to shoppers, without running your own site: Amazon Handmade, if you’re approved3.
  • A loyal following you can send to a link: Big Cartel, where the platform takes 0% of the sale6.
  • Shops already asking about wholesale: Faire, and bring them through Faire Direct to pay 0% commission89.
  • Your designs on products you don’t make by hand: Gelato or another print-on-demand service12.

If you want a full website rather than a shop page, two routes: Elementor builds on WordPress, and its Pro editor includes WooCommerce integration for online stores16. Wegic builds a site with AI; its Starter plan ($286.80 a year) shows products and collects inquiries, and a custom domain needs Premium ($502.80 a year)15.

Many sellers don’t leave Etsy outright. They keep their best sellers there and test one of these, which Big Cartel’s Etsy import and Amazon’s product transfer make easier36.

Decision flowWhich Etsy alternative fits you
  1. You sell to shops in bulk, at wholesale pricesFaire
  2. You make everything yourself and can pass an applicationAmazon Handmade
  3. You sell vintage or list hundreds of items a montheBay
  4. You'd rather pay a flat monthly price than a cut of each saleBig Cartel
  5. Your products are your designs, printed on demandGelato
  6. You sell a few pieces as a hobbyTedooo

A decision flow built only from the fees and rules cited in this guide.

Sources: [3] [4] [6] [8] [10] [12] · checked 2026-11-21Download image

Fees and payouts

Fees, plans and payouts

Amazon Handmade

Selling on Amazon Handmade

15% per unit

Seller pays 15% or $0.30, whichever is greater, per unit shipped · checked 2026-11-21

Seller fee
15% referral fee, minimum $0.30 per unit
Monthly fee
$39.99 Pro plan, waived for approved makers after the first month
Listing fee
None listed; you pay referral fees when you sell
Access
Application and approval required

eBay

Selling on eBay (no Store)

13.6% + $0.40

Seller pays on the total sale, including shipping and sales tax · checked 2026-11-21

Listing fee
250 free listings a month, then $0.35 each
Seller fee
13.6% up to $7,500, then 2.35% (most categories)
Per-order fee
$0.30 on orders of $10 or less, $0.40 above
Payout
Daily by default; bank typically 1-3 business days

Big Cartel

Gold

$0/mo

Free, no credit card · checked 2026-11-21

  • 5 product listings
  • Cards and PayPal
  • Sales tax autopilot

Platinum

$15/mo

After a 7-day free trial · checked 2026-11-21

  • Custom domain support
  • Shipping labels and tracking
  • Print on demand studio

Diamond

$30/mo

No commitment · checked 2026-11-21

  • Everything in Platinum
  • Abandoned cart recovery
  • Scheduled product drops

Faire

Selling wholesale on Faire (North America)

15% commission

Charged on the wholesale order subtotal · checked 2026-11-21

Seller fee
15% marketplace commission; 0% on Faire Direct retailers
New-retailer fee
$10 one time, on a marketplace retailer's first order
Payment processing
3.5% + $0.30 (next day), 2.4% + $0.30 (30 days), 1.9% + $0.30 (60 days)
Payout
Initiated after the order ships, on the schedule you pick

Gelato

Gelato (pay per order)

$0 upfront

You pay Gelato's product and shipping cost when an order comes in · checked 2026-11-21

Commission
None
Minimum order
None
Subscription
Optional Gelato+ for product discounts

Gains and trade-offs

What you gain, what you give up

Best for approved makers who want a big marketplace without a monthly plan fee15% referral fee per unit (min $0.30); Pro plan fee waived after month one · checked 2026-11-21

You gain

  • Gain: Professional plan fee waived for approved Handmade sellers after month one
  • Gain: You can transfer product details from an Etsy shop

You give up

  • Trade-off: 15% referral fee on every unit shipped
  • Trade-off: Custom (made-to-order) products can’t use Fulfillment by Amazon

Best for vintage and one-of-a-kind sellers who list a lot of items250 free listings/mo, then $0.35; 13.6% + $0.30-$0.40 per order · checked 2026-11-21

You gain

  • Gain: 250 zero-insertion-fee listings every month
  • Gain: Daily payouts by default, express payout for a $2 fee

You give up

  • Trade-off: Final value fee is charged on shipping and sales tax too
  • Trade-off: Extra 6% on fees if your account falls to Below Standard

Best for makers who want their own shop with a flat monthly priceFree for 5 products; Platinum $15/mo; Diamond $30/mo · checked 2026-11-21

You gain

  • Gain: 0% transaction fees on every plan
  • Gain: Imports products from Etsy

You give up

  • Trade-off: The free Gold plan stops at 5 products
  • Trade-off: Platinum costs $15/mo after a 7-day trial

Best for makers ready to sell wholesale to retail shops15% commission on marketplace orders (+$10 on a new retailer's first order); 0% on Faire Direct · checked 2026-11-21

You gain

  • Gain: 0% commission on retailers you bring through Faire Direct
  • Gain: You choose payout speed and its processing fee

You give up

  • Trade-off: 15% commission plus $10 on each new marketplace retailer
  • Trade-off: You sell at wholesale prices, not retail

Best for hobby makers who want a free, social place to listNo selling fees; optional Pro membership · checked 2026-11-21

You gain

  • Gain: Zero selling fees and unlimited listings
  • Gain: Handmade, vintage and secondhand items all welcome

You give up

  • Trade-off: Search priority and a Pro badge are paid Pro perks
  • Trade-off: Pro shops show at the top of search results

Best for designers who want print-on-demand products on several channelsFree to start; pay product + shipping per order, no commission · checked 2026-11-21

You gain

  • Gain: No upfront fees, no minimum orders, no commission
  • Gain: Connects to Etsy, Amazon, TikTok Shop, WooCommerce and Squarespace

You give up

  • Trade-off: You still need a storefront or marketplace to sell through
  • Trade-off: You pay Gelato’s product and shipping cost on every order

When to stay on Etsy

Stay if most of your sales already come from Etsy search and your shop is under $10,000 a year: you can opt out of Offsite Ads while you’re under that line, which removes the biggest fee in our example1. Stay if you value flexible payouts, since Etsy deposits daily, weekly, biweekly or monthly2 and offers instant transfer to eligible US sellers1. And if you want your own site without leaving, Etsy’s Pattern tool gives you one for $15 a month after a 30-day trial, and listings that live only on Pattern carry no listing fee1.

FAQ

Questions people ask

What does Etsy charge to sell one item?

A $0.20 listing fee, a 6.5% transaction fee on the item price plus shipping and gift wrap, and in the US a 3% + $0.25 payment processing fee on the order total12. On a $40 item with $8 shipping that is $5.01 before sales tax, or $12.21 if an Offsite Ad made the sale.

Can I opt out of Etsy Offsite Ads?

Only while your shop has made less than $10,000 in sales over the prior 365 days. Once you cross that line, you’re in the program at 12% on attributed orders for the lifetime of the shop, capped at $100 per order1.

Is Amazon Handmade cheaper than Etsy?

Not per sale on our example: Amazon Handmade takes 15% (minimum $0.30) per unit, against roughly 10.4% on Etsy for a $48 order without an Offsite Ad123. It can come out ahead on sales where Etsy’s 15% Offsite Ads fee applies, and approved makers don’t pay the $39.99 monthly plan fee after the first month3.

Which Etsy alternative has no selling fees?

Tedooo says it charges zero selling fees with unlimited listings10, and Big Cartel charges 0% transaction fees on all plans, with a free plan for up to 5 products67. Check the card processing rate for whichever payment method you connect.

Can I sell on Etsy and another site at the same time?

Yes. Big Cartel imports products from Etsy6, Amazon Handmade lets you transfer product details from Etsy3, and print-on-demand services like Gelato connect to Etsy and other channels at once12.

Sources

Sources

Small numbers in the text, like 1, point here. Each source shows the date we last checked it.

  1. 1Etsy Fees & Payments Policyetsy.com
  2. 2Etsy Payments Policy (payment processing fees by country)etsy.com
  3. 3Amazon Handmade: sell handcrafted goodssell.amazon.com
  4. 4eBay selling feesebay.com
  5. 5eBay: getting paid for items you soldebay.com
  6. 6Big Cartel pricingbigcartel.com
  7. 7Big Cartel Gold planbigcartel.com
  8. 8Faire: how much does it cost to sell if I'm based in North America?faire.com
  9. 9Faire Direct commission policyfaire.com
  10. 10Why sell on Tedooo?tedooo.com
  11. 11Tedooo Pro membershiptedooo.com
  12. 12Gelato pricinggelato.com
  13. 13Printify pricingprintify.com
  14. 14Tapstitch: print-on-demand appareltapstitch.com
  15. 15Wegic pricingwegic.ai
  16. 16Elementor pricingelementor.com

Updated . Spotted a fee that changed? Tell us and we will check it against the platform's own page.

Researched and written by

SoftwareAlternatives Editorial Team

We cover the platforms creators and sellers outgrow, why people leave them and where they switch, using each platform's own fee, payout and help pages with the date we checked them.